Item Priority Rankings
Anchor, Flare Gun, Flashlight
Duct Tape, Bucket, Bait, Fishing Rod
Swim Ring, Scuba Gear, Harpoon Gun, Captain Whiskers
Spyglass, Heart Piece, Heart Note, Message in a Bottle
Item Details
Anchor [S-Tier]
Source: Ship / Chest | <strong>Counters:</strong> Giant Squid, Whirlpool | <strong>Ending:</strong> True Ending route
The single most important safety item. Without Anchor, Giant Squid and Whirlpool are run-ending.
Flare Gun [S-Tier]
Source: Ship / Chest | <strong>Counters:</strong> Hope, Other People | <strong>Ending:</strong> Rescue (primary)
Primary rescue signaling item. Use during Hope events to signal aircraft. Do not waste on non-rescue events.
Flashlight [S-Tier]
Source: Ship | <strong>Counters:</strong> Hope, Shadow Figure | <strong>Ending:</strong> Rescue (backup)
Backup rescue item and Shadow Figure defense.
Duct Tape [A-Tier]
Source: Ship / Chest | <strong>Counters:</strong> Leak, Eerie Melody
Counters two different night events. Repair use is optional — save for event counters.
Bucket [A-Tier]
Source: Ship | <strong>Counters:</strong> Leak, Eerie Melody | <strong>Ending:</strong> Heart route
Versatile item for Leak and Eerie Melody events.
Bait [A-Tier]
Source: Ship / Events
Fishing requires Bait. Only consumed on catch (v1.1.2+). Effective until Day 60 in v1.1.3.
Fishing Rod [A-Tier]
Source: Ship
Daily food gathering. Requires Bait. Primary food source.
First Aid Kit [A-Tier]
Source: Ship
Heals 70% (buffed from 50% in v1.1.3). Critical for surviving dangerous encounters.
Night Event Counter Reference
| Event | Best Counter | Backup | Avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Giant Squid | Anchor | Repair next day | Going back to sleep |
| Whirlpool | Anchor | Immediate repair | No anchor |
| Eerie Melody | Duct Tape | Bucket / Umbrella | Flashlight / Spyglass |
| Eyes | Stay awake | None known | Sleeping |
| Hope | Flare Gun / Flashlight | Save Flare Gun | Ignoring the plane |
| Seagull | Shoo away | Feed (accepts food drain) | Letting too many stay |
| Leak | Duct Tape | Bucket | Ignoring it |
More Don't Sleep With The Fishes Guides